View objections to the planning application for a gravel pit at Lime Kiln Farm, Reydon by:-
- James and Emmeline Winterbotham
- Simon Loftus
Objection by James and Emmeline Winterbotham of Reydon Hall to Planning Application SCC/0039/19W Lime Kiln Farm Reydon (NOT Wangford) Suffolk IP18
The curious case of Suffolk County Council's addiction to quarrying in the AONB and its failure to protect the AONB at Reydon
Since 2016 Suffolk County Council has been aggressively pursuing a policy of expanding quarrying at the Wangford Quarry into a massive new site in Reydon. This is against a background of almost unanimous objection from local residents and a history of failure to enforce rules protecting the AONB and to hold developers to account.
The Council has a duty to protect the AONB but has consistently failed to do so
The Council will be aware of the long history of this contentious site and the Council's failure over a long period to protect this part of the AONB.
When earlier applications were made to include the current site within the 1998 Plan and when the extension into Wangford Covert was approved Planning officers consistently advised against further quarrying at the Wangford site as being inappropriate within the AONB but were over-ruled by Councillors. Officers' advice clearly accepted that mitigation would not be acceptable, and would permanently harm the AONB. In 2006 Planning officers reported to Councillors
"Policy requires that the prime consideration be given to the impact upon the integrity of the AONB. There are short to medium term adverse effects on the visual amenity of the immediate area arising from screen bunding and excavations. The landform created through mineral working, in combination with the adjacent working and the approved doming of the landfill site adjacent to the north, would result in a landform of artificial appearance alien to the landscape character of the area. The application is therefore recommended for refusal." (Note 1)
Councillors ignored this advice and approved the next phase of quarrying and destruction of AONB.
In 2013 an application for a solar farm in Reydon was also opposed by the Planning officers but again over-ruled by Councillors. Subsequent analysis on behalf of the National Trust concluded that Councillors failed to understand the rules."The AONB Partnership objected to a proposal for a solar array covering 10.7 hectares with 18,000 panels as the proposal would introduce industrial scale development to the protected landscape. The officer agreed that the 'proposal constitutes a conspicuous feature that is alien to the character and appearance of the local landscape', and recommended refusal. Members approved the proposal, however, but used reasons for departing from their officers' recommendation which did not properly apply national AONB policy." (Note 2)
This area of land has suffered almost ribbon development between Reydon and the A12. It would be a failure of their duty were Councillors to approve the proposed new quarry.
The Council does not enforce conditions laid down as part of planning approvals
In the case of the Wangford quarry as noted above conditions have been waived or deferred over many years, depriving residents of the promised public access as compensation for continued quarrying.
In the case of the Reydon Solar Farm the same story applies. The farm remains an eyesore and commitments by AEE to plant hedges and provide grazing land for sheep have not been enforced. Residents have had to agitate to get something done five years later.
SCC consistently turn a blind eye to the ribbon development West of Reydon village.
The Council is inexplicably addicted to quarrying in the AONB
It would appear that Cemex never believed that they would get permission to quarry in Reydon. Their right to extract minerals on the land they acquired in 1985 expired in 2015. It was Graham Gunby at SCC who insisted that Lime Kiln Fields be included in the Plan in 2017 and has encouraged Cemex to pursue the application.
SCC appear to have played along with Cemex to disguise the nature of the application - accepting the wrong designation of location as Wangford and not noticing that the parish boundary is being crossed, an error that continues in the current application.
SCC have ignored the obvious alternative source of gravel - marine - despite Cemex being the principal holder of offshore licences in East Anglia and annually dredging 4m tonnes for export to London and the Continent. SCC have not listened to Cemex's competitors - Brett, Tarmac and customers of ABP, who run the port of Lowestoft - who all believe that marine aggregate will be the future.
For as long as SCC permits cheap onshore quarrying in the AONB there is little incentive to go elsewhere. Wangford quarry is probably one of the most profitable quarries in the UK. Why is SCC so keen to see Cemex continue to profit?
The original submission into the 2016 Suffolk County Minerals Plan envisaged a 2m tonne resource at Lime Kiln – potentially key to the Plan and providing 20% of Suffolk’s needs. But in the revised application this is now seems to be less than 600,000 tonnes of aggregate ie less than 10% and hardly strategic. Not enough to justify destruction of the AONB.
The case against approval of the quarry at Lime Kiln Fields is overwhelming and local opinion almost wholly opposed. But even if Planning executives recommend refusal SCC has form in ignoring reason and fairness. This must not happen again and Councillors must be held to account.
Sources
1. Suffolk County Council DC06/02,26th January 2006 Brief Summary para 8
2. National Trust, AONBs and Development 2015 page 10
James and Emmeline Winterbotham
Reydon Hall
Reydon
IP18 6SJ
14th June 2019